As Civil Beat’s journalists came into the newsroom on Thursday, many of us were thinking about the toxic legacy of Hawaiʻi’s most harmful fuel spill.
It was the fifth anniversary of the week jet fuel from the Navy’s massive World War II-era storage complex at Red Hill gushed some 20,000 gallons into its underground tunnels, located directly over Oʻahu’s drinking water supply. Our top story that day recounted how the disaster sickened thousands of people, some of whom are still struggling with health impacts.
Then, mid-morning, we learned there had been an even bigger leak of 400,000 gallons of diesel — 20 times larger than Red Hill — at H-Power, the city-owned incinerator in Kapolei. The parallels are hard to ignore: Like at Red Hill, there had been an apparent failure in leak detection and a delay in informing the public, and there are big questions about contamination, accountability and remediation.
In H-Power’s case, the city contractor, Reworld, discovered that fuel had been spewing from an underground pipeline for months, from January through May, soaking fuel into the soil around the facility. Mayor Rick Blangiardi says he didn’t find out the full scope of it until Tuesday of this week. The public learned at a mayoral press conference on Thursday.
Officials answered the most obvious question: Is our drinking water at risk?
Ernie Lau, the chief engineer of the Honolulu Board of Water Supply, assured the public he has no reason to believe the H-Power fuel leak could jeopardize the area’s drinking water, in part because the nearest well is located a few miles away and is uphill.
Lau earned a lot of public trust during the Red Hill debacle, but with so much at risk, folks aren’t necessarily taking his word for it. Incoming City Council Chair Tyler Dos Santos-Tam and Councilwoman Andria Tupola are both calling for independent environmental testing and required public notification going forward.
Officials said much less about possible impacts to the ocean, either from fuel-tainted groundwater or runoff from contaminated soil. Blangiardi only said he doesn’t expect there to be shoreline impacts. Some experts are already expressing concern to Civil Beat about that.

Much is still unknown about the H-Power incident. But as journalists, we can look to the past to chart the course forward for our news coverage.
Some of the topics we’ll be asking about in coming weeks:
- The hydrogeology of Kapolei. As we learned in this story about Red Hill, much of how water travels through Oʻahu’s aquifers is unknown, which can make it challenging to know how pollution will travel underground. Kapolei’s landscape is different than at Red Hill, and we’re trying to get a better understanding of it.
- Fuel tracking systems. At Red Hill, the Navy had had problems keeping track of how much fuel was where. That allowed for some 20,000 gallons of fuel to go unaccounted for in a May 2021 leak. That fuel reappeared months later and contaminated the drinking water in November 2021. H-Power’s contractor also apparently was losing fuel for months before it realized what was happening. We want to know how their leak detection system was supposed to work and how it failed.
- Accountability. To our knowledge, the military leaders at Red Hill faced few consequences for running the facility in a manner that sickened thousands of people. Some got letters of censure. Two civilian employees were criminally charged with conspiracy and making false statements to regulators. They pleaded not guilty, and their case is pending. Who will be held responsible for the mess at H-Power? The EPA, which enforces the Clean Water Act, is already investigating.
As a reporter, I ran point on Civil Beat’s coverage of Red Hill — we’ve published 244 stories, columns and community voices to date — and now, as an editor, I’m using that experience to guide our team as we cover another environmental mess.
We’ll be using the lessons we learned in the last fuel disaster, as well as new research and reporting, to inform our questions about the H-Power fuel leak. If you have questions you want us to ask or suggestions about where to look for information, please shoot us a note at news@civilbeat.org.
Delayed Disclosure, Deja Vu
First, a recap.
On the day of the disastrous Red Hill leak — Saturday, Nov. 20, 2021 — fuel spewed into the Red Hill well, which supplied drinking water to some 90,000 people on Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam. Workers struggled to stop or contain it. Fuel rained down for 34 hours straight. For days, the military didn’t tell anyone their water was at risk.
“There are no signs or indication of any releases to the environment,” a Navy press release said on the Monday following the leak, “and the drinking water remains safe to drink.”

So, the week of Thanksgiving 2021, people drank the fuel-tainted water. After family meals of turkey and mashed potatoes, they washed their dishes in it. They bathed their children in it.
And people started getting sick. They threw up. They had vertigo. Kids had rashes. Some went to the hospital. They didn’t know what was going on and were being told everything was fine. Later, they felt gaslit.
The public only got confirmation they weren’t crazy when the state health department published a notice on Nov. 29 — more than a week after the catastrophic spill. The Navy didn’t admit there was a problem until three days later.
The Navy’s denial in those early days caused irreparable damage to public trust. People still talk about it years later.
The (obvious) lesson learned: People want to know right away when there is a possible threat to public health.
In the case of the H-Power incident, Blangiardi said he will be assessing why he didn’t find out about the scope of the problem sooner. As for the state health department, Director Ken Fink said his subordinates didn’t post about the leak in the public database called iHEER – run by the Hazard Evaluation and Emergency Response Office — because the case is still open.
We plan to ask experts whether it makes sense for the health department to wait for a case to be closed before telling the public about a major contamination incident.
The Public Has A Right To Public Information
Our reporting on Red Hill was greatly helped by people willing to stick their necks out and explain to us, both on and off the record, how the facility worked and where things went wrong. Some brave soul even gave us the only video the public has ever seen of the leak itself.
I’d like to pause to personally thank those sources for helping us get to the bottom of things on behalf of our readers.
A lot of other information stayed hidden. I made many Freedom of Information Act requests that the military simply ignored.
This keeps public information hidden and further erodes public trust.
The lesson: The public wants transparency.
In the hours after we learned of the H-Power leak, Civil Beat journalists combed through public records that are readily available online. We found EPA and OSHA violation notices and a scathing decade-old city audit that says the contractor, Reworld, was able to secure a 20-year extension on its contract, apparently without city officials realizing what they were agreeing to.
Since then, Civil Beat has filed public records requests to learn more about H-Power’s operations, Reworld’s contract records, how this fuel spill was able to go on undetected. Essentially: Who knew what when? We hope government agencies will err on the side of disclosure.
See Something, Say Something
It’s important to remember that even after the Red Hill leak sickened thousands of people, the Navy still intended to keep the facility open. They wanted to continue using it for fuel storage above Oʻahu’s drinking water aquifer.
Meanwhile, Civil Beat continued to cover the risks and impacts and victims and activists banded together, using our journalism as fodder for their demands. “Shut Down Red Hill” became a rallying cry at protests and a message found on bumper stickers and cafe posters.



Only in the face of overwhelming public and political pressure did the defense secretary at the time say they would close it. And that was a big deal, because the Navy had said for years that Red Hill was an essential national security asset. (See here in a 2015 press release that hasn’t aged well.)
The lesson: Journalism informs not just officials but everyday people, who have the power to band together and demand change and accountability — and it can make a big difference.
If you have information about H-Power, Reworld or other environmental risks to our community, we want to talk to you. It could be the start of something important.
