The people of Oʻahu have spoken: Data stewardship belongs in local government.

This month, 71.1% of voters said “yes” to Question 15, establishing a permanent Office of Data and Innovation under the Honolulu City Charter. The office gives the City and County of Honolulu’s chief data officer a charter-protected home, shielded from the whims of future luddites in the mayor’s office.

The outcome signals a growing appetite for data-driven government. For Hawaiʻi’s arts, however, that enthusiasm came with more strings attached in the Legislature.

Consider the failed House Bill 2117, which would have established the Mapping of Arts Data for Education (MADE) task force to inventory arts programs on a public geographic information system (GIS) map: who’s offering what, where, and to whom. The data could expose gaps in K-12 arts education and inform funding decisions.

Despite the bill’s demise, the initiative survived through a sister measure: House Concurrent Resolution 162, introduced in the session’s final weeks and later adopted.

Same task force. Same ambition. Only this time, the resolution requested a task force rather than mandating it by law. A weaker legal commitment, but a common fallback for bills that fail to pass on their first attempt.

Now, the newly assembled task force must make the case for investing in itself before it can make the case for investing in the arts.

From Bass to Bill

HCR 162 calls for 13 representatives from Hawaiʻi’s arts, education, government, and data sectors, with room for additional members, to build the state’s first arts education database.

Randy Wong, president and CEO of Hawaiʻi Youth Symphony (HYS), is designated to convene and chair the task force. For Wong, 45, the mission is personal.



Ideas showcases stories, opinion and analysis about Hawaiʻi, from the state’s sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea or an essay.

Growing up in Honolulu, he struggled with a severe speech impediment and was teased for his slight frame and “stick legs.”

“If you don’t feel sure of yourself, if you’re worried about what people think of you, you don’t want to participate in class,” Wong said. “It’s hard to feel like you really have any self-worth.”

That began to change in third grade, when he picked up the double bass in his required music class. All it took was a simple request from the teacher.

“Randy, will you pluck the string of the bass?” he recalled his teacher asking. “Do it again. I like that.”

For the first time, Wong felt comfortable participating. Someone genuinely wanted to hear his voice.

Wong went on to play bass in HYS, study music at Boston’s New England Conservatory, and earn a master’s degree in Arts in Education from the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

He returned home in 2012 as HYS’s executive director and joined the Hawaiʻi Symphony Orchestra.

Chamber Music Hawaiʻi performs with Hawaiʻi Youth Symphony students at Moanalua Public Library. (Courtesy: Hawaiʻi Youth Symphony)

“I’m back home, and I feel like it’s my duty,” Wong said.  “It’s my calling to help other kids access music because of what it did for me, and what it did for so many of my friends.”

That sense of purpose planted the seed for the task force.

Nearly a decade ago, Wong sought to identify music “deserts” across Hawaiʻi, only to discover that neither the Department of Education (DOE) nor nonprofit arts leaders had comprehensive data on K-12 arts offerings.

Wong brought the problem to lawmakers in 2025, including Rep. Jeanne Kapela, chair of the House Committee on Culture and Arts. The following session, she introduced HB 2117 and later HCR 162, both proposing a task force to establish a statewide arts education database.

Connecting the Dots

The other organizations named in HCR 162 bring different perspectives and expertise to the task force, helping ensure no single organization’s interests dominate.

The State Foundation on Culture and the Arts (SFCA) and Hawaiʻi Arts Alliance (HAA) contribute knowledge of existing arts programs. The DOE, along with private and charter school representatives, offers a fuller picture of arts education across the islands.

ESOL students work on identity-based self-portraits under the guidance of teaching artist Zoe Liu during an Artists-in-the Schools residency at Stevenson Middle School. (Courtesy: Hawaiʻi Arts Alliance)

And because the goal is a GIS map, Hawaiʻi Data Collaborative (HDC) and the state’s GIS program manager get seats at the table, too.

Rep. Kapela and Sen. Chris Lee, who helped advance the measures through the Legislature, are also represented on the task force through their positions as arts committee chairs.

All task force members are volunteers.

Thomas Lee represents HDC, a nonprofit promoting data access and public decision-making. As director of government partnerships, Lee submitted the charter amendment proposal that became Question 15.

Lee’s background is in data, not the arts, but his experience with HYS drew him to the task force.

“I personally advocated for it just because I grew up playing music,” Lee said. “I know if someone is exposed to music in the DOE system or in a private school, you’re more likely to succeed in school. But we don’t have a lot of data to support that locally.”

For Lee, data helps move beyond intuition when evaluating policies.

“No one’s just basing it off gut or experience,” he said. “We want the data to help us inform whether or not policies or initiatives are actually making the impact that they’re intended to.”

Gaye Humphrey, HAA’s executive director and task force representative, wants arts mapping to expose disparities in access. HAA expands arts education through programs like Artists-in-the-Schools, in partnership with SFCA.

NPAC student Gevanie-Denise Reyes, a Nanakuli Elementary School fourth grader, rehearses in the Nanakuli High and Intermediate School Multi-Purpose Cafe Thursday, Aug. 212, 2024, in Waianae. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)
Gevanie-Denise Reyes, a Nanakuli Elementary School fourth grader, rehearses in the Nanakuli High and Intermediate School Multi-Purpose Cafe in 2024 in Waianae. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)

“With data, we can really understand where opportunities are for arts learning, where the gaps are,” she said. 

“Does a child growing up on Molokaʻi have access to the same range of arts opportunities as a child in Honolulu? If the answer is no, then we need to be thinking about how we can solve that.”

The task force also hopes to break down institutional data silos. Until now, no statewide effort has attempted to bring records together for public access.

“It’s natural that certain organizations or systems collect data for their own purposes and use it only internally,” Wong added.

“There just hasn’t been really a thinking around what it will look like when we have open data and use it for a larger purpose than just internal metrics.”

Deadline Without a Dime

Teaching artist Zoe Liu (center) guides ESOL students through painting techniques during an Artists-in-the Schools residency at Stevenson Middle School, supported by the State Foundation on Culture and the Arts and Hawaiʻi Arts Alliance. (Courtesy: Hawaiʻi Arts Alliance)

Neither HB 2117 nor HCR 162 provided funding, although Rep. Kapela’s committee asked House Finance to consider an appropriation.

Under HCR 162, the task force is expected to deliver initial findings on Hawaiʻi’s music and dance programs before the 2028 legislative session, followed by a comprehensive report on all arts disciplines before 2030.

The resolution is nonbinding, with no clear consequences if named organizations stop participating. Still, Wong says attendance and engagement have remained consistent since monthly meetings began in September.

Members have begun designing a survey to inventory arts programs and consolidate the information into a statewide GIS map. But getting that information won’t be straightforward.

Lee says some organizations may be reluctant to share data for community use. Wong and Humphrey say even DOE representatives struggle to extract arts education information from the department’s systems.

Sculptures and drawings created by students in the Kahauiki Village After-School Arts Enrichment program, which provides arts instruction during after-school hours and school breaks. (Courtesy: Hawaiʻi Arts Alliance)

With little arts education data publicly available on DOE’s website, much must be gathered directly from schools.

While middle and high school music programs are easier to identify, elementary offerings are harder to track. Many schools rely on general education teachers or visiting artists rather than dedicated arts specialists, leaving much of that instruction unaccounted for in DOE staffing records.

Even basic questions, such as which schools employ arts specialists, what disciplines they teach, and how many students they serve, take considerable effort to answer.

Despite these challenges, Wong remains optimistic.

“It’s going great, great, great,” he enthused. “We’re making progress every month. This is a very thoughtful and action-oriented group of people.”

To make the case for future funding, though, the task force must first demonstrate what it can accomplish. Can dedication alone carry volunteers meeting once a month through their first report?

In the end, the data will tell us.

Jenny "Jeta" Tang is a columnist for Civil Beat.