Waikīkī, the bustling heartbeat of Hawaiʻi’s tourism industry, doesn’t usually spring to the top of lists of economically depressed neighborhoods and low-income communities.

Yet, much of the neighborhood north of Kalākaua Avenue is now being described that way by the state, which has selected it for a federal program intended to spur investment in downtrodden areas through tax breaks that can include big capital gains tax savings. 

The governorʻs office says the move is aimed at benefiting both residents and visitors by improving the area’s older residential buildings and hotels on the side streets makai of Ala Wai Canal stretching to Kalākaua Avenue.

“From a tourism point of view, the hotels are needing to go through a refresh to keep up with competition. But there’s also aging housing stock there,” said Scott Glenn, Gov. Josh Green’s senior advisor for federal affairs, climate and housing. “This can be a financing tool to help with housing as well as the tourism and economic development side.”

Elsewhere on Oʻahu, tracts were selected in Iwilei, Chinatown, the North Shore, Wahiawā, ʻAiea and Mōʻiliʻili. In West Oʻahu, the Kalaeloa tract — 3,700 acres of a former U.S. Navy air station — was chosen. Economically struggling Westside communities such as Waiʻanae and Nānākuli were not, though both were eligible under the guidelines.

Data on the federal program’s outcomes is limited because it previously lacked robust reporting requirements, experts said. But it has been criticized for benefiting relatively wealthier neighborhoods, which based on some data have attracted the most investment, and because states can’t control what projects get the tax breaks the program provides.

However, economists say Hawaiʻi is taking advantage of the program in the best way it can, and the state is exploring how to direct investment to projects it wants to support.

Glenn was on a team of state officials Green chose to select the so-called opportunity zones. The Treasury Department gave the state a list of 88 census tracts it determined were eligible to be zones under poverty and household income guidelines. Hawaiʻi was allowed to choose 25. 

Five of Hawaiʻi’s 25 new economic opportunity zones are located in Waikīkī. (Screenshot/Hawaiʻi State Office Of Planning/2026)

Nineteen zones were chosen on Oʻahu, five in Waikīkī. The world famous district — home to glitzy businesses ranging from Chanel to La Mer to the Ritz-Carlton —  accounted for nearly $9 billion in tourist spending in 2024. But it also has a large population of retirees and service industry workers with limited and lower incomes among its roughly 20,000 residents. 

In those zones, “typically, there are much smaller, older buildings with cheaper rent there and the people that are living there aren’t necessarily the wealthiest,” said Steven Bond-Smith, an economist with the University of Hawaiʻi Economic Research Organization. 

Eligible census tracts had to have a poverty rate of at least 20% or a median family income 70% or below that of the metropolitan area or state.

It is the second round of the program, with designations lasting a decade. While the Waikīkī tracts were eligible before, this was their first time being selected. 

Some in the neighborhood questioned the decision, saying the program wouldn’t ultimately benefit residents.

“If you wanted to give somebody local a tax break to build something, then I could understand. But what you’re really doing is you’re just bringing in people who already have a ton of money. They could afford to pay the taxes,” said Todd Ferguson, a Liliʻuokalani Avenue resident who works for the nearby Ala Wai Golf Course.

Moped riders turn toward Diamond Head onto Cleghorn Street from Kapīli Street between an empty, overgrown lot and run-down Waikīkī apartment buildings Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, in Honolulu. Waikīkī rarely evokes visions of an economically depressed neighborhood and low income community. But the state now defines parts as opportunity zones under a federal program intended to spur investment in downtrodden areas through an array of tax breaks. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2026)
Cleghorn Street sits in one of the new economic opportunity zones in Waikīkī. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2026)

“As a local resident, I don’t get any tax breaks, and neither does anybody else around here,” Ferguson said.

But others said the approach held promise.

“It’s a good idea if they are smart about their resource spending and if it’s more toward helping the community,” said Jason Song, who lives in Kakaʻako but owns Discount Vapes on Kūhiō Avenue.

The state should ensure investments go toward a mix of business and housing projects, Song said, and housing that is developed should be affordable.

“It should be for bringing in tourists or new housing,” he said, “but not charging astronomical prices for rent if they’re gonna use tax breaks.”

Some Struggling Communities Excluded

While the absence of communities such as Waiʻanae, where 27% of residents live below the poverty level, from the list of zones stands out, economists and elected officials said that was likely due to obstacles they face including a lack of ongoing investment, challenges including limited access and traffic congestion, and a lot of property that is Hawaiian homelands, making it harder to develop projects.

“We don’t have large swaths of land there where a developer is going to come in and bring houses or businesses,” said Honolulu City Council member Andria Tupola, who represents West Oʻahu. “We definitely need it in Kalaeloa. It’s basically no man’s land out there.”

Aerial drone view of Waianae, with Farrington Highway extending out
Though West Oʻahu is often seen as an area with a greater need for economic investment, no communities on the Waiʻanae Coast were selected for the program. (Kuʻu Kauanoe/Civil Beat/2021)

The program is best suited to benefit zones already experiencing some economic investment and growth, experts said.

“What we’re seeing it less likely and able to do is take an extremely disinvested neighborhood and make a market there,” said Brady Meixell, a senior research associate at the Urban Institute, a nonpartisan research organization. “The market fundamentals still have to be in shape to bring investment into an area.”

That, Bond-Smith said, means the state had to focus on areas where pre-existing opportunities make greater returns on investment more likely.

“Waikīkī, particularly the more rundown parts of Waikīkī, there’s probably some big investment opportunities there that will generate a bigger return for investment in Hawaiʻi than investments in Nānākuli,” he said.

In selecting the zones — their designation lasts 10 years — the state team focused on issues ranging from housing to energy and healthcare projects, Glenn said. The need for housing was the chief criterion guiding decisions, and the speed at which projects could get up and running was another.

Glenn said the first question the team usually asked was, “Is there an opportunity for housing here?”

Two zones on Maui were named. One — Lahaina’s Front Street — was ruled eligible only after state and county officials and University of Hawaiʻi Mānoa economists convinced the government that the neighborhood, destroyed in the 2023 wildfire, desperately needed investment.

Four zones on Hawaiʻi island were also named in last week’s announcement, three in Hilo and one in North Kona.

In a statement, Green, a physician, said that with early investment in places where resources are scarce, “you prevent a lot of pain down the road.”

“That’s as true for our communities as it is for our patients,” he said. “These designations will catalyze investments to build a healthier and more affordable Hawaiʻi for our local people.”

Few Guardrails

Experts who researched the first round of opportunity zones have varied perspectives on how they have worked so far.

Based on data from Ohio, which required investors who made use of the tax breaks to include that on their state tax returns, new housing was the main outcome, Meixell said.

“People thought it would be more of a small business program in some cases,” Meixell said. “But for a lot of structural reasons based on how the incentive is given, it really has become more of a housing program.”

Hawaiʻi is pursuing the best use of the program by focusing it on tracts with better odds of attracting investment in new housing, Meixell said.

Other experts said the program also has too few guardrails when it comes to what investors choose to do; for example, the state cannot select which projects get the tax breaks.

“There’s nothing to force investors or even encourage them to do things that benefit the low income people who live in an opportunity zone,” said David Wessel, senior fellow in economic studies at Brookings Institution, a nonpartisan policy research group.

A view of Shipwreck's Beach on the south shore of Kauai. (Nathan Eagle/Civil Beat/2016)
At least a dozen projects on Kaua‘i’s South Shore, a hub of hotels and tourism activity on island, appear to have taken advantage of the last round of economic opportunity zone designations. (Nathan Eagle/Civil Beat)

Wessel, who has written about how the program has favored the wealthiest zones, said that nationally, real estate projects other than housing have attracted more investment through the zones.

“The challenge is we’re talking about private investors, rational, profit seeking private investors who are going to go for the highest return possible with the lowest risks. And in many cases, that has been hotels rather than housing,” he said. 

Likewise, Wessel said, “a lot of the housing has been more like the high end condos because they’re more profitable.”

On Kauaʻi, the two zones selected in the 2018 round included the resort community of Kukuiʻula and Hanalei. Projects there have included the purchase of a $1.87 million vacation rental in Poʻipū, a $721,000 vacant parcel in Kukuiʻula and a proposed $227 million resort and wellness center in Poʻipū that never got off the ground. 

No Kauaʻi tracts were eligible in the latest round.

In Waikīkī the five zones cover an area that stretches roughly from Ala Wai Boulevard to Kalākaua Avenue and Nāhua Street, from Ala Wai Boulevard to Kūhiō Avenue and ʻŌhua Avenue to Kaʻiulani Avenue, and from Kūhiō Avenue to Kalākaua Avenue and Kaʻiulani Avenue to Kapahulu Avenue.  

Those areas of ​​Waikīkī, with some older hotels and apartment buildings whose age and conditions have kept rents lower, “might be just the place where a little bit of a tax break could provide some incentive to get some investment there,” Wessel said. “I just hope they get the housing and not just the renovated hotels.”

Steering Investment

On its second go round, “Hawaiʻi is being innovative” in its approach to the program, trying to fashion ways to best leverage the tax breaks and direct investment to the types of projects it wants, Meixell said.

Some strategies the state is considering: Making it cheaper for opportunity zone investors to borrow money, aligning state and federal tax laws to investors’ advantages and creating portfolios of projects to bring multiple investors together to lower their individual risk, said Gwen Yamamoto Lau, executive director of the Hawaiʻi Green Infrastructure Authority.

There are three tax benefits for investors in opportunity zones: They can temporarily put off paying taxes on capital gains they invest in a zone; if they leave their money invested for at least five years, they pay less tax on those profits; and if they hold onto an investment in a zone for at least 10 years before selling it, they pay no capital gains tax at all on the new profit, potentially a major jackpot.

Rebar in an empty Waikīkī lot at Tuitala Street and Liliʻuokalani Avenue is photographed Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, in Honolulu. Waikīkī rarely evokes visions of an economically depressed neighborhood and low income community. But the state now defines parts as opportunity zones under a federal program intended to spur investment in downtrodden areas through an array of tax breaks. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2026)
A vacant lot on Liliʻuokalani Avenue, which sits in a newly designated economic opportunity zone. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2026)

Money invested in opportunity zone projects must be placed in what are termed opportunity zone funds; the state hopes those may also be a way to steer capital toward the types of housing and other projects it wants to see.

For example, Yamamoto Lau said, it might be that investors in a luxury housing project would start their own fund to do that and qualify for the tax breaks, however they might not be eligible for state support.

“We cannot stop investors from doing what they want. But we can encourage investors in things that are important to us,” she said.

The opportunity zone program, the nation’s largest ongoing federal community economic development initiative, produced $100 billion in investment overall in its first round, with Hawaiʻi getting an estimated $310 million of that. It’s projected to cost the federal government more than $40 billion between 2025 and 2034.

“Compared to other states, we’re lagging a little bit on opportunity zone investments,” Yamamoto Lau said. “We really want to ramp that up.”

That’s desperately needed in Kalaeloa, an area of more than 3,300 residents that was selected as a zone in the first iteration, too, Tupola said.

“Honestly, it had zero impact,” she said, attributing that to zoning rules put in place by the Hawaiʻi Community Development Authority, which is responsible for regulating housing in the area, and a lack of infrastructure.

“We need to make a better plan and pitch it to someone willing to invest,” Tupola said. “It could help in any of the private sector things that the district needs.”

The opportunity zone will be just one tool in driving investment there, she said, along with business improvement districts and state enterprise zones, which also offer tax incentives.

“We have 10 years to figure this out. And in government terms, 10 years is kind of fast,” she said. “So we have to get on this right away.”

Jeremy Hay is a reporter covering economic inequality for Civil Beat.