After a decade of delays and protests, the Thirty Meter Telescope is at a pivot point — either move forward or completely languish. On Thursday, the state took a small step that suggests the project is on the move again.
The state Board of Regents voted Thursday to allow construction of new telescopes on Mauna Kea on land where old telescopes have been decommissioned and removed. It’s a step that may help clear the way for TMT but possibly trigger more controversy and protests.
E. Kalani Flores, a cultural practitioner who has been deeply involved in the opposition to TMT, predicted it will never be built despite the Thursday vote by the regents.
“It’s a waste of effort and time on everybody’s part,” Flores said in an interview after the regents’ vote, “but it’s a last ditch effort by UH and whoever else is supporting the TMT to try to make it look as though they have a chance to build on Mauna Kea.”

“What they’re really trying to do is they’re trying to give some hope to the TMT project, that they still have an opportunity to build on Mauna Kea,” Flores said.
Many astronomers view the TMT project as essential by for unraveling mysteries of the universe. It has been stalled since 2019 after thousands of Native Hawaiians and their supporters protested and blocked construction on Mauna Kea, but officials with the TMT International Observatory have been quite clear they still want to build the telescope there.
Conflict Between State Law And Master Plan
The regents’ vote this week amended what is officially known as the Master Plan for The University of Hawaiʻi Maunakea Lands E Ō I Nā Leo (Listen to the Voices), which applies to an area at the summit that is controlled by the university. That area is generally acknowledged to be the best site in the world for conducting astronomy, because of little water vapor at its 13,803-foot-high summit.
The problem was the university’s master plan specified that five of the 14 telescope sites on Mauna Kea would be “ineligible for future astronomy use” after the telescopes were removed.
That language conflicted with a 2022 state law known as Act 255 that specified decommissioned sites on Mauna Kea are to be prioritized over undisturbed sites for new telescope construction.
The amendment that was unanimously approved in the vote by the regents on Thursday removed the reference in the master plan that made decommissioned sites “ineligible for future astronomy use.”
The master plan still acknowledges the UH has “committed to reducing the number of operating astronomy facilities” in the area of the mountain the university controls, which has slowly been happening. The UH’s Hōkū Keʻa telescope has also been removed, and the United Kingdom Infrared Telescope (UKIRT) has begun the decommissioning process.
Kumella Aiu urged the regents to vote against the amendment, saying “I think our community has been very clear on where we stand on the issue of Mauna Kea, and I don’t think it changes just because we decide to do it differently.”
Fengchuan Liu, TMT’s project manager, has told the regents “we believe we can” construct the huge new telescope on the former site of a decommissioned telescope site, and TMT has studied the former Caltech Submillimeter Observatory site as a possible site. The Caltech facility was removed from the mountain in 2024.
TMT has also inquired with both the regents and the Mauna Kea Stewardship and Oversight Authority (MKSOA) about the possibility of building on a site where a previous telescope has been removed.

Liu said in an interview Mauna Kea continues to be TMT’s preferred site and is “the site we are focusing our effort on, but we understand respecting the community and getting the community’s support is paramount.”
Many people have asked why the telescope cannot be built on a decommissioned site, he said, and TMT is looking at that possibility even though it has a permit to build at another location on the mountain. The TMT board last October inquired about the permitting process that would be involved in shifting the project to the site of a decommissioned observatory.
“We don’t want to rush this, we want to do what’s right, and this is why looking at a decommissioned site is part of it,” Liu said.
Costs Have Escalated
Flores predicted TMT will not be built because it will face an outpouring of opposition from Native Hawaiians and other opponents, and because the project lacks the funding it needs for construction.
The mountain is considered sacred land to many Hawaiians, and the 2019 protests that blocked construction of TMT attracted participants from across the state. The issue became a focus of Hawaiian activism, cultural revival and the sovereignty movement.
The cost of the project has escalated as TMT has been delayed for the last 10 years, and it is unclear where the backers of the project will get the money necessary to finally build the telescope.
A report for the National Science Foundation in late 2024 calculated the total cost of the TMT project would be $3.9 billion, and indicated $700 million had already been spent by that point.
At the time the five partners in the project had committed $1.7 billion, and were expected to contribute a total of $2 billion in cash and in-kind contributions. Additional partners were being sought, and the project sponsors hoped to convince the NSF to provide another $1.6 billion.
That has not yet happened. The NSF in 2025 instead announced plans to fund the Giant Magellan Telescope in Chile, leaving TMT in a kind of funding limbo.
Operating the telescope is expected to cost about $60 million per year, a figure that sponsors expected would increase during the project’s 50-year lifetime, according to the report.
The Thirty Meter Telescope International Observatory is a partnership of institutions in Japan, Canada, India and the U.S., including both the California Institute of Technology and the University of California.

TMT’s primary mirror would be 30 meters in diameter, and would gather between nine and 16 times more light than the largest existing optical and infrared telescopes. Liu said the project will allow astronomers to explore some of the most profound mysteries of the universe.
The plan is to use the telescope to explore mysteries such as the relationship between black holes and galaxies and how stars and planets form. It is ideally suited for finding planets outside of our solar system, an ability that could contribute to the search for life elsewhere in the universe.
“We have some fundamental questions we just don’t understand,” he said, including the nature of the mysterious “dark matter” and “dark energy” that make up some 95% of the mass-energy in the universe.
The TMT would help astronomers to see farther and in more detail to try to answer “all of these questions, what is the universe made of, are we alone, how did the universe and galaxies evolve over the years,” he said.
