For months, the Maui County Board of Water Supply has struggled to effectively review proposed developments, advise local officials on matters related to resource management and fulfill other legally prescribed responsibilities.
That’s what board’s chair Nichole Inouye-Nohara maintains, blaming it on the planning director’s repeated refusal to participate in board proceedings.
“This is more than a matter of attendance. It directly impairs the Board’s ability to discharge its responsibilities under the Maui County Charter,” Inouye-Nohara wrote in a draft Oct. 17 letter to Mayor Richard Bissen. “There is a rather remarkable mis-apprehension of the kuleana of the Board of Water Supply within the administration.”
On Thursday, the board unanimously voted to approve the letter, in which Inouye-Nohara formally requested that Bissen direct the planning director, Jacky Takakura, to publicly appear before the board and provide a written explanation of the Planning Department’s responsibilities to confirm the availability of water resources when reviewing subdivision and land-use proposals.

“The Board is not seeking to interfere with the Planning Department’s lawful administrative authority. Rather, it seeks the cooperation necessary to perform its own Charter-mandated advisory function,” Inouye-Nohara wrote in the letter.
Takakura’s insufficient participation perpetuates ambiguity regarding Planning Department procedures and responsibilities, impairs the board’s ability to advise the mayor and County Council, and undermines cooperation among county departments, according to an attachment to the letter.
The letter was drafted after months of attempts by the board to engage Takakura in discussions to answer questions about department responsibilities, streamlining coordination among the departments of Planning and Water Supply and reviewing legislation being considered by the County Council.
Water Is At Center Of Dispute
Takakura has provided written responses to questions provided by the board, according to a statement from a county spokesperson Wednesday. She also appeared at an Oct. 15 meeting, but the board declined to hear from her and deferred their scheduled discussion about the department’s responsibilities related to securing water supply for subdivision applications.
“Director Takakura has made every effort to appear when requested at BWS meetings, declining only when she has had conflicts with her schedule,” according to the statement.
Responding to the board’s letter requesting Takakura’s presence at the 1:30 p.m. meeting on Oct. 15, a planning department secretary said in an email that the director was already scheduled to attend an in-person meeting at 2 p.m. on the same day.
Takakura did attend the meeting, though, and the board shuffled the agenda around so that they took up their discussion with her immediately after public testimony concluded at 1:41 p.m. However, members chose to reschedule the item so they would have more time to speak with Takakura, according to the meeting minutes.
Inouye-Nohara first reached out to Takakura on April 3, soon after Takakura assumed the helm of the Planning Department following the resignation of former planning director Kate Blystone.
“We would appreciate your perspective on how water supply is evaluated for commercial and private development, how the Planning Department tracks overall water supply conditions across Maui, and how these considerations are addressed at various stages of planning,” Inouye-Nohara wrote to Takakura in an email inviting her to attend the board’s meeting on May 21.
In her response, Takakura told Inouye-Nohara that some of those topics had previously been addressed by Blystone when the former director met with the board. “That might have been a year ago,” she wrote, then sharing excerpts from the Maui County Charter specifying the duties of the departments of Planning and Water Supply.
Director Participation ‘Integral’
After Takakura did not attend the meeting on May 21, the board invited her to participate in another meeting over the summer.
“Our goal is to improve water resource planning for Maui’s future and streamline coordination between the Planning Department and the Department of Water Supply in the development of infrastructure improvements for a reliable water supply and emergency response,” Inouye-Nohara wrote in the draft letter to Takakura. “Through previous discussions with past-Director Blystone and staff members from the Department of Water Supply, we have identified what appear to be important gaps in the planning process regarding to countywide water supply.”
At the end of the letter, Inouye-Nohara attached document explaining why the board felt that it was imperative to meet with Takakura and outlining several questions requesting information about who specifically in the department can evaluate water use and supply, Takakura’s assessment of Maui’s water supply and resource planning process, and how the department tracks cumulative water usage and supply throughout the county.
In her response, Takakura declined to address most of the board’s questions, instead sharing a department organization chart and referring members to the charter.
The Maui County Charter expressly establishes the planning director as a “non-voting ex-officio member” of the Board of Water Supply, and therefore Takakura’s participation “is not merely an optional courtesy between departments” but an integral part of the board’s institutional structure, according to an attachment to Inouye-Nohara’s letter. Additionally, the board relies on access to information about planning decisions and administrative procedures to advise on issues like water-resource availability, system capacity and future water demand, according to the attachment.
Takakura previously told Civil Beat that she had only agreed to take on the role of planning director for the remainder of Bissen’s current term, which runs through the end of this year.
Shay Chan-Hodges, the former water board chair whose term ended in 2021, said she couldn’t speak to the current situation or the current administration. However, the importance of departmental collaboration is clear, she said.
“Obviously the use of water is crucial to any kind of development and housing, which has come up over and over again,” Chan-Hodges said. “Communication overall, I think generally has not historically been great at the county. ”
