Cheryl Ryan isn’t optimistic that she will get back any of the $30,000 Rocky Aviguetero owes her for work on her backyard pool, which she says he never finished.
But the teacher sued the unlicensed contractor in September anyway after a pool resurfacing job this spring turned into a horror show by June.
“I’m sitting here beating myself up for having trusted him. There’s a lot of shame associated with falling for this,” the Kāneʻohe resident said. “I now have a hard time hiring and trusting other people.”
Ryan’s pool, it turns out, was just a sample of the trail of damage that Aviguetero’s been accused of leaving behind. Once she started looking, Ryan quickly found there were others who said they had paid Aviguetero for projects never completed and materials never delivered.
In court records, Ryan discovered three civil claims against Aviguetero worth more than $55,000 from the last four years and another 16 claims or civil suits against him dating back as far as 1988. Courts have entered a dozen default judgments against him since 2008. And those were only the cases, like Ryan’s, that ended up making it to court.
Aviguetero, who hasn’t hired a lawyer in the last seven years, turned up for only one online hearing in all that time, according to a review of court records by Civil Beat.
The Department of Commerce & Consumer Affairs also sued Aviguetero in 2008 and got a court to impose a $15,000 fine against him and his then wife for contracting without a license on Kauaʻi. Details of the complaint that led to the fine are not readily available online, and the court docket doesn’t specify if the fine was ever paid.
In Hawaiʻi, engaging in contracting activity without a license is a misdemeanor crime that can become a felony if done habitually. But the court judgments against Aviguetero have been in civil court and were not related to licensing issues.
Ryan’s situation is illustrative of the the difficulty consumers have when trying to hold an unlicensed contractor accountable in Hawaiʻi. Their options — seeking recourse either through the courts or the state’s licensing agency — are apparently not enough to stop some accused bad actors from operating.

That discovery only fired up Ryan more.
“I went through the shame process, and now I’m just in the angry process,” she said. “The only thing I can do is make sure this doesn’t happen to other people.”
There are two other pending consumer complaints against Aviguetero from this year and 2024, according to the Hawaiʻi Regulated Industries Complaints Office website. Separately, DCCA issued a cease and desist letter to Aviguetero in 2024 for allegedly selling unregistered securities.
Attempts to contact Aviguetero by phone, text and email were unsuccessful.
Despite this lengthy pattern of allegations about unethical behavior and the financial harm to consumers, Aviguetero remains active.
After he talked Ryan into an “off-the-books” deal, took cash deposits and partially completed the project, he stopped working and failed to return nearly $24,000 and unused materials as agreed, Ryan’s lawsuit alleges.
Landscape Worker Offered To Help
Ryan first met Aviguetero in March when she called Koʻolau Landscaping, a licensed landscaping business based on Oʻahu’s Windward side.
She wanted four coconut trees on her property removed, and Aviguetero turned up in a Koʻolau Landscaping truck and uniform to provide a quote for the work. The work was done well, and she paid him $3,500 and $200 tip, according to her lawsuit complaint.
Ryan said that Aviguetero’s role as a Koʻolau Landscaping employee was one of the reasons that she hired him for the pool work.
That’s when he said he could also do other backyard projects through a separate arrangement, she said.
“You really need to have your pool resurfaced. I got a guy who can help you with that. I’ll do the prep work, and he’ll come in and he’ll do the plaster and we got you,” Ryan recalls Aviguetero saying.
Aviguetero represented that he was licensed and qualified, according to her lawsuit complaint. She said she later discovered that neither were true.
He then told her that if she could pay cash, he would get a better price for materials.
“It’s better for you. It’s better for me,” she recalls him saying. Ryan said it was not the first time somebody’s asked her for cash to do a job and thought, “OK, it’s worked out before.”
Ryan kept a detailed record of the timeline of the work and provided Civil Beat with documentation of payments, statements, receipts and text messages related to the project.
On April 6, Aviguetero said he paid $475 for the pool renovation permit, the complaint states. Ryan said she later discovered that wasn’t the case, the lawsuit says.
A week later he texted that he had secured the materials for the pool renovation and asked for $10,000 in a cashier’s check and $8,000 in cash, the complaint states. That was followed by a $1,098 payment for permit processing and tiles, the lawsuit states, and $7,760 for electrical work and additional materials.

Then on June 22, Ryan got a text from Aviguetero’s son saying that his father was in hospital for emergency surgery, the lawsuit states. Throughout July, he offered “various excuses and promises to send others to perform the work,” but no one came, according to the lawsuit.
On Aug. 18, the court filing said Ryan spoke with Aviguetero and they made a verbal agreement that he would return $23,460 and materials to her, the lawsuit alleges.
Aviguetero didn’t respond to a text message from Ryan documenting the agreement, according to the filing.
Aviguetero has been employed by Koʻolau Landscaping, company owner Asher Eisenpress said in a text last week.
“However he did not have authority to represent the company or sign contracts on its behalf. Koʻolau Landscaping did not provide a quote, enter into an agreement, perform any work or receive any payment,” for the work on Ryan’s property, Eisenpress said.
Eisenpress did not respond to a follow-up question about whether Aviguetero is still employed by the company.
Ryan says she’s resigned to the fact she likely won’t get her money back from Aviguetero.
“That’s hard for me to swallow. I’m a school teacher and I’ve been working really hard to save up the money to make these improvements on my house,” she said. “And ultimately he screwed me over.”
Ryan has a court date scheduled for next month.
Latest From Civil Beat
Licensing Rules Not Always Enforced
In Hawaiʻi, anyone doing construction or contracting work that is more than the bare basics — painting and minor drywall, non-structural woodwork and yard maintenance — needs to have a license. The only exception is for handymen doing projects that cost less than $1,500.
Depending on the scope of the work, contractors in Hawaiʻi working on a pool need one of three license types, including for full construction, renovation and repairs, and to install prefabricated hot tubs and above ground pools.
Aviguetero doesn’t have any of those, state licensing records show.
Rogue operators like Aviguetero are just the tip of the iceberg, said Steve Maratta, the owner of Aquatic Solutions. His company ended up fixing Ryan’s pool at a discount rate, Ryan said.
Maratta said the practice is far more widespread than the enforcement records show. Unlicensed or improperly licensed companies do pool construction and renovations all the time, Maratta said. His company has been registered in Hawaiʻi since 2012, has 15 employees and an annual revenue of $8 million, he said.
Maratta said that in his opinion, the state Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs is not doing enough enforcement against contractors like Aviguetero or larger companies that aren’t licensed for pool construction.

“When I was living in Las Vegas, the municipality would really go after these guys,” he said.
In Nevada, even submitting a bid for work valued at over $1,000 without a license is a criminal offense, even if no work is done. And after three strikes, it becomes a felony.
California, Arizona and Florida regulations allow agencies to go as far as conducting sting operations and jobsite sweeps on pool construction site. They even use undercover investigators to catch unlicensed operators.
Esther Brown, who heads the state industry complaints office, did not return a message left with her office Monday.
A Civil Beat review of the last six years of DCCA’s unlicensed enforcement actions shows only two times that a pool company or a contractor was fined for doing work without the required license.
Neptune Pools and Spa Service based in Honolulu was fined $5,000 in June for carrying out work as a specialty pool contractor without a valid contractor’s license.
The company’s co-owner, Alish Fernandez, said their license lapsed through an oversight and they were working to get certified again, but the process is expensive and cumbersome for small family businesses like hers.
Maratta filed a formal written complaint with the DCCA in June about a different company he said was doing a backyard pool project without proper licensing. The agency informed him that they had closed the case after sending a warning letter.
Meanwhile, Maratta holds a pool construction license in addition to general building and engineering licenses, and even so, his company has not been immune from enforcement action. His company was fined $8,500 after consumer complaints about the quality of work related to his pool projects were filed in 2021 and 2023.
Few Options For Consumers Wronged
If a contractor abandons a project or fails to deliver materials, homeowners can be reimbursed up to $12,500 per contract through a state recovery fund, with maximum total compensation capped at $25,000 per individual contractor.
But the fund only applies to cases involving contractors who are licensed. The consumer also has to win a civil judgment in court first, and the contractor needs to show they are unable to pay.
The options for consumers narrow quickly when it comes to unclicensed contractors.
“Then you’re just dealing with another person,” Ryan’s attorney Addison Bonner said. “Your remedies are essentially trying to negotiate a resolution or filing a breach of contract.”

It becomes even harder if the customer did a cash deal for promised discounts.
“Then it becomes a question of what that cash was paid for,” he said, “and whether that cash was paid at all.”
Ryan’s lawsuit against Aviguetero alleges breach of contract, deceptive business practices and unjust enrichment. She is seeking damages and attorney fees, the filing shows.
Under certain circumstances, consumers could file a police report, if for example, a contractor asks for a deposit to buy materials that never appear.
“That could be theft, in my mind,” Bonner said, but added as a former prosecutor, charges would be an unlikely outcome.
Ryan did talk to police, she said, and they told her to take civil action.
“I can’t guarantee that there’s going to be any recovery.”
Attorney addison bonner
Ryanʻs experience with Aviguetero is similar to Kapolei resident Shannondore Cuesta, who paid him $11,100 for soil, bricks, concrete and irrigation equipment for a yard project that he never finished, according to her detailed court filing this year.
She and her husband just got a default judgment for the full amount plus costs against Aviguetero. She declined to speak on the record.
Chelita Muratsuka paid $10,500 starting in November 2022 to install artificial turf at her Mililani residence that she alleged in her court filing was never completed. She managed to get a default judgment against Aviguetero in 2024, but the court records show the court order sent to Aviguetero was returned in the mail.
Garrett Yamamoto of Wahiawā hired Aviguestero to have his yard leveled and artificial turf installed. Now he is out of pocket nearly $4,000, court records state.
Even if the courts rule in favor of consumers like Ryan, court records suggests they are unlikely to recoup money from Aviguetero, who has multiple tax liens and other judgments, according to background checks.
Bonner said that his law office fields calls from consumers like Ryan on a weekly basis, but in most of the cases, it may not be financially worth pursuing, “unless we’re well into the six figures.” The attorney’s fees may exceed any potential award.
“I can’t guarantee that there’s going to be any recovery,” he said.
Is Your Contractor Licensed?
Working with licensed contractors offers more protection for Hawaiʻi consumers. Here are some available resources.
Is the contractor licensed?
Ask the company or contractor for their license numbers. Some contractors list them on their website while others do not. You can verify a professional license at the state’s Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs websites here. Search business registrations here.
DCCA also publishes a list of licensed contractors, electricians and plumbers and engineers, architects, land surveyors and landscape architects.
What licenses are required?
A license is required for any work that is valued at more than $1,500. So anything more than light handyman work like painting or non-structural woodwork likely requires a licensed contractor. Check if the job requires a specific license.
Have they ever been sanctioned for working without a license?
You can search through judgments and disciplinary actions here and here.
Does the contractor company have a history of complaints from consumers?
Check the Regulated Industries Complaints Office website for records of any complaints.
