Stacy Ferreira reached out to the Attorney General’s Office asking for help. The Office of Hawaiian Affairs CEO hoped the state’s top law enforcement agency would investigate what she saw as misconduct by OHA’s board.
She claimed the board’s chair, Kai Kahele, had leaked private budget information to outside entities and coerced executive team members to “fraudulently” certify a budget — allegations she claimed might violate laws or policies.
Attorney General Anne Lopez has often emphasized that her office does not share information on pending matters so as not to jeopardize a potential case. Case information, her office has said, is confidential.
But apparently this one was not, according to records released by OHA this month as part of two internal investigations into the agency’s unfolding drama. After getting Ferreira’s tip, Lopez allegedly contacted Gov. Josh Green’s office. And then Green’s communications director Makana McClellan allegedly alerted the subject of the complaint: Kahele.
“The Attorney General found it problematic that the CEO would solicit an investigation of OHA,” Kahele told an investigator, explaining how he learned about Ferreira’s complaint. “So much so that she contacted the Governor’s staff, and the senior-most staff member contacted me as the Chair to inform me.”

Lopez’s office did not respond to questions about why her office notified Green’s staff about the complaint. An investigator hired by OHA ultimately found Ferreira’s claims without merit.
Nevertheless, the suggestion that the state’s top cop would leak information to the governor and trigger a notice to the target of a complaint has sparked concerns among legal experts. The allegation seems to directly contradict the AG’s insistence that the office’s work is confidential and that the office is independent from political influence. And legal experts said it raises doubt about the office’s credibility with future whistleblowers, who often fear retaliation from those they’re complaining about.
“We have problems if the system is rigged or leaked to the point where a whistleblower feels that they’re going to have their confidential information disseminated,” said Alexander Silvert, a retired federal public defender. “That’s going to be an issue with coming forward.”
AG’s Office spokeswoman Toni Schwartz said in a statement that the AG conducts investigations independently and is committed to “protecting the integrity of those investigations.”
McClellan declined to discuss the situation and did not respond to requests to interview Green.
“We cannot comment on pending legal matters,” she said.

The report doesn’t say why the AG may have found Ferreira’s report “problematic,” as Kahele stated, but it notes Ferreira as CEO was supposed to get approval from the Board of Trustees before seeking a legal opinion from the AG’s Office, which she didn’t do.
Ferreira directed a reporter to her attorney who did not reply to a request for comment. Bill Brennan, OHA spokesman, said Kahele was traveling and unavailable for comment.
After Kahele was informed about the complaint against him, the Office of Hawaiian Affairs put Ferreira on leave. Ferreira then sued Kahele and the Board of Trustees, claiming he put her on leave in retaliation for making the report with the AG’s Office. That lawsuit is pending.
Latest From Civil Beat
OHA had hired two independent firms to investigate Ferreira’s claims against Kahele as well as allegations against Ferreira, including that she failed to disclose a romantic relationship with a nonprofit founder who was in the running for a grant and that she obstructed passage of the office’s 2025 budget.
The Hawaiʻi Whistleblower Protection Act is supposed to shield the type of retaliation Ferreira claims she faced. Though the statute doesn’t address when and how the AG’s Office is allowed to share information about complaints, whistleblowers who come forward have an expectation of confidentiality when they file complaints, said Scot Brower, a Honolulu attorney who specializes in whistleblower cases.
Having the target of a complaint find out about it too soon could compromise any investigation, he said.
“The person who’s allegedly committing the crime, they could destroy their records, they could hide stuff, they could take a plane out of town,” he said, speaking generally. “That’s why they have secret grand jury proceedings, because you don’t want the target to know what’s going on.”
‘Prosecutorial Independence’
Hawaiʻi’s attorney general has a unique position providing legal counsel across state government to the governor, the Legislature and executive agencies. This means that lawyers within the same department may serve clients with distinct, and sometimes competing, interests.
Simultaneously, as the state’s top law enforcement office, the attorney general may also be called upon to investigate those clients.
That split role has, at times, attracted scrutiny.
Lopez held a press conference in February to assure the public that she could operate completely independently of the governor who appointed her as she investigated some of his colleagues in the state’s most recent bribery scandal. The case centers on a local businessman who allegedly bribed state officials to secure lucrative Covid-19 testing contracts during the pandemic.

During the press conference, Lopez assured reporters that she hadn’t shared any information with the governor about the investigation that hadn’t already been made public. At the time, a coalition of government accountability advocates had called on Lopez to get a special prosecutor to investigate the corruption case, saying Lopez couldn’t conduct a fair investigation into Lt. Gov. Sylvia Luke, Green’s No. 2.
But Lopez also assured the public that she wouldn’t be influenced by politics.
“This prosecutorial independence is really important,” she said at the time. “And it’s one that (Green) and I have talked about since the very beginning and that we have both been committed to — that I promised I wouldn’t be a politician, and he promised that that prosecutorial independence is crucial to this department.”
Five months later, an Oʻahu grand jury indicted Luke, three other state officials and a lobbyist in a sweeping conspiracy case. A trial is scheduled for Aug. 2.
Green was vocal throughout the investigation that he was frustrated by its slow pace. On April 14, he told Hawaiʻi News Now’s “Spotlight Now” program that he expected to have an answer about Luke’s role in the case by the following Monday. That Wednesday, Luke’s attorney at the time, David Louie, confirmed she had received a target letter in the investigation. The following day, Luke announced she would take a leave of absence from her role as lieutenant governor.
Green’s press secretary, Erika Engle, said in an email the AG often briefs Green on “matters that will be made public. Such briefings are distinct from providing substantive updates on an active investigation.”
But the revelations about the OHA complaint have brought concerns about information sharing to a new level.

In Silvert’s opinion, the information about the OHA complaint had no reason to reach the governor’s office. Leaks like this further blur the lines of independence and undermine public trust in the justice system, he said.
“If a complaint’s filed, at some point you have to tell the person who the complaint’s against that there’s been a complaint filed against them so that they can respond,” he said. “That’s just due process.”
But, he added, “You’re not supposed to hear it from the executive branch.”
Robert Harris, executive director and general counsel of the state Ethics Commission, said the state law prohibits state employees from disclosing confidential information they learned through their work.
For example, in 2023, a former legal clerk for the AG’s Office was cited $1,000 for violating the state code of ethics by emailing confidential information about a lawsuit to the opposing counsel. Back in 2019, an OHA board member was found to have violated the ethics code by disclosing information from executive session meetings. She was fined $1,500.
In the case of the AG’s office sharing information about the OHA complaint with the governor’s staff, it isn’t clear whether the existence of the complaint would be considered confidential, Harris said. Some information, such as people’s medical information, is deemed confidential by statute, while other types of information are agency specific and internal policies dictate what is considered confidential and what’s not.
Schwartz, the AG’s office spokesperson, did not respond to requests to provide any internal office policies regarding sharing information about pending investigations and the handling of whistleblower complaints.
She did say, however, that “as a general matter, the Department of the Attorney General does not disclose the existence or status of investigations” in order to “protect and maintain the integrity of the investigative process.”
She did not respond to a follow-up question about why, according to Kahele’s account, the office disclosed information about the OHA matter.
Elected vs. Appointed
Even though AGs are appointed by the governor, the governor can’t unilaterally fire them, unlike other department heads that serve at the pleasure of the governor. Removal of an attorney general requires a two-thirds vote of the Senate.
This, some experts say, gives the AG a level of autonomy and independence. But critics of the model say it doesn’t make the AG independent enough.
The governor can choose a new AG every time he or she reorganizes his cabinet, as Green has done. Green announced last week that Lopez’s first deputy, Matthew Dvonch, would succeed her. His appointment requires Senate confirmation.

Dvonch declined a request to discuss what level of confidentiality the AG’s office, under his leadership, will apply when it receives a request for an investigation.
Camron Hurt, executive director of the government accountability group Common Cause Hawaiʻi, thinks the state should explore a constitutional amendment to require that attorney generals be elected, as they are in most other states.
Hawaiʻi is one of only five states where the governor appoints the attorney general.
“I believe that everybody truly does want to be independent, but how are you independent from your boss?” Hurt said. “If your boss is the people, then that’s who you’re working for, and those are the people who are going to hire and fire you, and I think that makes much more sense.”
The Legislature did consider a bill in 2016 to make the attorney general and judges elected. Then-state Sen. Gil Keith-Agaran, who introduced the bill, said he did so just to start a conversation about the idea.
“I thought it was worth a listen, since we are an outlier,” he said.
The bill passed the Senate and was referred to the House Judiciary Committee, where it did not get a hearing. Then-state Rep. Karl Rhoads, who was chair of the committee at the time, said he didn’t like the idea of politicizing the role of attorney general. The provision of state law shielding AGs from being fired by governors in the middle of a term, in his view, is sufficient to ensure their independence.
“I think that’s a good safeguard,” he said.

While two individuals who testified in favor of the bill said they supported the idea and felt it would give more power back to the people, three former attorneys general testified against it, as did as Doug Chin, who was attorney general at the time.
Requiring attorneys general to campaign for re-election would distract them from their duties, Chin said. And asking them to fundraise could also subject them to accusations of being influenced by campaign contributors.
“If an attorney general is not acting with the independence the State Constitution contemplates, then that attorney general should be reminded of the unique prerogative the State Constitution accords to the office,” he wrote. “It should not be necessary to abandon what has been the practice under the law in Hawaii for more than 150 years.”
