Mimi DesJardins will be Maui County’s next chief legal adviser in the new year, and Andrew Martin will stay on as prosecutor.

The Maui County Council unanimously confirmed Mayor Richard Bissen’s nominees despite DesJardins’ past “missteps” as a judge and concerns about transparency in the selection process.

The Maui County Council unanimously approved Mayor Richard Bissen’s appointment of Mimi DesJardins, left, to the role of corporation counsel. Victoria Takayesu, who has held the job since 2023, intends to remain with the department as first deputy to Desjardins. Erin Nolan/Civil Beat/2026

In response to a question about whether there were any details about her past that she would prefer to disclose on her own terms, DesJardins acknowledged her 2013 decision to resign as a family court judge after she was charged with tampering with a government record to keep an arrested person in custody for more than 48 hours. She pleaded no contest to the charge, which was brought after she entered incorrect times on multiple judicial determination of probable cause documents, The Maui News reported at the time.

DesJardins was sentenced to 300 hours of community service and ordered to make a $2,000 contribution to the state general fund, according to The Maui News. The conviction was kept off her record as long as she followed the court’s requirements and went one year without an additional arrest.

The experience inspired DesJardins to further study legal procedures, she said, and it taught her the importance of resisting outside influence and remaining impartial when offering legal advice.

“I made a terrible judgment error, and it cost me my career as a judge,” she said, adding that she spent years beating herself up for her mistake. “Up until that point, I had never, ever had any kind of disciplinary proceeding or action against me, and then after that, I never had a disciplinary action.”

DesJardins said in her 37-year career, she unfortunately “hit a pretty high mark in making a very poor judgment,” and she hopes her past decade as a county attorney inspires confidence that she has become a better lawyer for it.

Council Chair Alice Lee expressed her support for DesJardins while acknowledging that fact.

“I really respect the work she’s done with us. We’ve worked with her for eight years, and for some of us even longer,” Lee said. “I can tell you that no one’s perfect. No one in this room or anywhere else. You know, we’ve all made some missteps from time to time. The overall picture is important to me.”

Council members recognized the public’s concerns for seeming to rush to confirm the appointment before the new council is sworn in Jan. 2 and without adequate time to vet DesJardins.

They acknowledged that Bissen chose a nominee without input from the Independent Nomination Board, which was approved by voters in 2022 and established in 2024 to improve transparency surrounding the nomination process.

Latest From Civil Beat

Council member Keani Rawlins-Fernandez explained during Friday’s council meeting that the mayor was legally granted the authority to unilaterally appoint his picks for corporation counsel and county prosecutor after the board missed the County Charter-prescribed deadline to submit names to be considered for both positions.

“What may look like a rush, because it’s the end of our term and before the new term, is not us rushing. It’s what the charter mandates us to do,” said Rawlins-Fernandez, who represents Molokaʻi. “It’s unfortunate that the timeline was set up the way it was, but this is the timeline in the charter.”

In the Nov. 3 election, voters narrowly rejected a charter amendment introduced by Rawlins-Ferndandez that would have dissolved the Independent Nomination Board and changed deadlines related to the nomination process.

Rawlins-Fernandez said that while she disagreed with the process, she supported the appointment of DesJardins, who has worked closely with the council over the last three years as first deputy corporation counsel to Victoria Takayesu.

“She has really helped me a lot with legislation. She is always super responsive and quick,” Rawlins-Fernandez said. “I really appreciate her ensuring that when she is giving advice, that she is separating legal advice, the law, and then the policy — which is our lane, which is our kuleana — and she makes sure to empower us in policymaking decisions and not interfere with that.”

Takayesu, who has served as corporation counsel since she was appointed by Bissen in January 2023, told council members that she intends to remain with the department as first deputy to DesJardins, council member Kauanoe Batangan confirmed Friday. 

During a Government Relations, Ethics and Transparency Committee meeting on Thursday, Bissen said he had “tremendous respect” for DesJardins’ legal expertise, sound judgement and commitment to public service.

“She has earned my trust and confidence not only through her knowledge of the law, but through her integrity, professionalism, and thoughtful approach to some of the most difficult challenges facing our county,” he told the council. “What I especially appreciate about Mimi is her approach to leadership. She listens, she collaborates, and she understands that effective legal counsel is not simply about identifying challenges, but helping find responsible solutions that allow us to move forward while upholding the law.”

As first deputy to Takayesu, DesJardins played an important role in helping the administration navigate the unprecedented legal complexities that arose out of the 2023 wildfires and advance initiatives related to post-disaster recovery, he said. She has also advised the council on legislation related to the county’s ties to federal law enforcement agencies and the implementation of Maui’s new safe parking pilot program for residents living in their vehicles.

DesJardins said she was deeply honored by her appointment and genuinely excited about the opportunity to lead the department. 

The Maui County Council unanimously approved Mayor Richard Bissen’s appointment of Mimi DesJardins to the role of corporation counsel. (Erin Nolan/Civil Beat/2026) Erin Nolan/Civil Beat/2026

“What motivates me today is the same thing that drew me to the law many, many years ago: the opportunity to help people, to solve problems, but most importantly, to make a positive difference,” she said. 

After Friday’s vote, DesJardins and Takayesu smiled and embraced. It was the first of many hugs that she accepted from council members and county staff. 

The Department of Corporation Counsel currently employs about two dozen lawyers, and there were two open positions, DesJardins told council members last week.

DesJardins graduated from the University of Puget Sound School of Law, and she has worked for Maui’s Department of the Corporation Counsel since 2018, according to her resume. 

She worked as a per diem judge for six years and as a family court judge for about a year before she pleaded no contest to tampering with a government record and resigned. 

In addition to years as a public defender and as a private practice attorney focused on family law, DesJardins taught classes about the justice system at the University of Hawaiʻi Maui College.

Prosecutor Gets Another Term

All nine council members voted to confirm the reappointment of Maui County Prosecuting Attorney Andrew Martin to a second term. 

“I’ve really enjoyed every single time I’ve spoken with you. I found you to be very present. You pause, you listen, and it’s really refreshing to talk with someone and feel that it’s reciprocated,” said council member Tom Cook, who represents South Maui, during Thursday’s meeting. “You’re good at what you do, and the community’s lucky to have you.”

Martin has has successfully prosecuted high-profile criminal cases, including those related to the fatal shooting of Maui Police Officer Suzanne O and a Lahaina man convicted of 16 counts of sexual assault against a child. He recently made headlines when he publicly disputed the Maui police chief’s claim that the mayor was being criminally investigated by the Hawaiʻi Attorney General.

Maui Prosecuting Attorney Andrew Martin who is in charge of the Family Assistance Center speaks at a press conference Tuesday, Aug. 22, 2023, in Wailuku. The gathering was to share information on those missing and the process to identify remains found in the Aug. 8 Lahaina wildfire. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2023)
Maui Prosecuting Attorney Andrew Martin will continue serving in his role. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2023)

When asked to discuss his thought process leading up to his decision to comment on the chief’s remarks, Martin said he felt it was his ethical responsibility to correct misinformation that had been shared with the public.

“That wasn’t a political statement,” he said. “It was a statement to set the record straight.”

He added: “Had I not corrected that statement, to be honest, I would have felt like a coward, and that I wasn’t doing the right thing, so I issued the statement. It speaks for itself as to the independence of the prosecutor’s office and the work that we do.”

Martin said he does not take direction from the mayor or the council on how to conduct investigations.

While most of the council expressed their enthusiasm to approve Martin’s reappointment, Lee took a moment before Friday’s vote to express that she had some reservations. 

“I do support him overall. I think his performance has been overall good,” she said, adding that she did not like the way he handled a lawsuit filed by a former Bissen administration employee.

Leo Caires, Bissen’s former chief of staff, sued the county in April, accusing the mayor of retaliation after Caires raised concerns about potential fraud and financial mismanagement by other county employees.

Latest From Civil Beat

Erin Nolan is Civil Beat's Maui reporter.