Kamehameha Schools has asked a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit challenging its more than 140-year-old admissions policy that gives a preference to students of Native Hawaiian ancestry.

The school was created from the estate of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop at a time of steep population decline among Native Hawaiians and shrinking opportunities for education. That estate now controls land and financial assets valued at well over $15 billion.

Last October, the group Students for Fair Admissions sued the school alleging that its admissions policy discriminates against non-Hawaiians and violates parts of the Civil Rights Act. 

In court and in legal filings, the group’s attorneys have turned prior civil rights cases on their heads: lawsuits originally intended to fight the segregation of Black and other minority students are being used in an attempt to pry open Kamehameha’s doors to other races too.

Lawyers and Kamehameha’s supporters have painted the lawsuit as not just an attack on the admissions policy but an assault on Native Hawaiians that seeks to take resources meant for them.

“This lawsuit,” Kamehameha lawyer John Bash said during a hearing Tuesday, “is trying to siphon off this wealth for the benefit of other people.”

The admissions policy is one of several landmark Hawaiian programs facing legal attacks including the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act — which guarantees a homestead lot to those who can prove they have 50% or more Hawaiian blood — and a Native Hawaiian health scholarship.

Kamehameha Schools CEO Jack Wong, middle, and legal counsel Joachim P. Cox, back, mingle with students, staff, and trustees at the conclusion of a gathering, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, at Kawaiahao Plaza in Honolulu. The hearing begins Tuesday in U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaii on Kamehameha Schools' motion to dismiss a federal lawsuit challenging its Native Hawaiian admissions preference policy. (Jamm Aquino/Civil Beat/2026)
Kamehameha Schools CEO Jack Wong, middle, and attorney Joachim P. Cox, back, mingle with students, staff ahead of a key hearing on Tuesday. (Jamm Aquino/Civil Beat/2026)

“We enter this courtroom with the law on our side and an unwavering understanding of who we serve.”

Crystal Rose, chair of Kamehameha School’s board of trustees

The admissions policy has been challenged at least three times before, with Kamehameha prevailing in each case. School officials remain confident they’ll be able to beat back this lawsuit as well.

“We enter this courtroom with the law on our side and an unwavering understanding of who we serve,” Crystal Rose, chair of the school’s board of trustees, said during a rally at Kamehameha’s downtown headquarters Tuesday morning. 

Rose was an attorney for Kamehameha 20 years ago, during the first admissions lawsuit.

Mason Fong, a senior at Kamehameha Kapālama, said students now have a duty to speak up and protect the school for future generations.

“Pauahi saw a future for us before we were born,” he said. “Today, we stand for the keiki we have yet to meet, so they have a place at Kamehameha.”

Hearing Focused On Admissions

Kamehameha students, all dressed in the school’s signature Navy blue polos, trustees and other school officials packed the federal courthouse for Tuesday’s hearing so much so that the court opened an overflow room for attendees who wanted to watch the hearing live.

As Kamehameha lawyers adorned with green maile lei took their seats and the legal team for the SFFA appeared on Zoom, court security took the unusual step of addressing the packed courtroom, warning that outbursts could result in immediate removal from the courthouse.

The princess did not create Kamehameha “as an ordinary school teaching reading, writing and arithmetic,” KS attorney Bash told the court, “but to preserve Native Hawaiian culture and Native Hawaiian sovereignty for her people.”

Bash asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit because the initial complaint filed in October 2025 included just the Students for Fair Admissions as plaintiffs representing two unidentified families, neither of whom actually applied to Kamehameha.

His other argument centered around the ability of two other plaintiffs added later, I.P. and E.S., to continue in the case. School lawyers have previously said that neither teen had the scores to advance to a stage of the admissions process where ancestry would be considered.

Students from Kamehameha Schools line up outside of the federal district courthouse
Lines of students, media and Kamehameha School officials snaked around the steps of the federal courthouse prior to the hearing. (Blaze Lovell/Civil Beat/2026)

The school has a two-step admissions process. In step one, applicants face a battery of tests and either participate in interviews or a classroom visit. Composite scores are compiled based on that stage as well as their recommendation letters and report cards from their previous schools.

Once applicants are ranked, the top scorers are offered seats and only then does ancestry come into play, according to a court declaration from a school admissions official.

Are Contracts Race-Based?

Based on his line of questioning, District Judge Micah Smith did not appear inclined to grant Kamehameha an outright dismissal of the case. Rather, he implied that he would allow Students for Fair Admissions and the other plaintiffs to amend their complaint and investigate Kamehameha’s claims that ancestry is not considered in the initial stages of the application process.

But attorneys for the plaintiffs said doing so could be unfair to them as it may result in the plaintiffs having to argue the core of their case — the admissions process — in front of the judge at a relatively early stage instead of in front of a jury.

“It’s the whole case: How does the admissions process work?” plaintiffs attorney Cam Norris said.

Latest From Civil Beat

In opposing the school’s motion to dismiss the case, Norris argued that because Hawaiians are not federally recognized, they are considered a race, like white, Black, Asian and Hispanic. He pointed to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Rice v. Cayetano that eliminated Native Hawaiian-only voting in elections for the Office of Hawaiians Affairs as well as decades of court rulings that have struck down segregation of schools based on race.

Part of the SFFA’s case revolves around a section of the Civil Rights Act having to do with protection from discrimination in contracts. Since then, Kamehameha has attempted to recast its relationship with students as providing a gift in the form of free tuition instead of entering into a contract.

After Kamehameha made tuition free for all students last year, the Legislature, attempting to aid Kamehameha, subsequently passed a law that said such arrangements are considered gifts and not contractural obligations.

Norris said contracts between Kamehameha and its students still exist if there’s an implicit agreement that students receive a diploma at the end of their schooling. And he said contracts exist at Kamehameha in the form of such things as housing agreements, medical waivers, sports participation agreements, and even use of campus vending machines. And if those contracts are race-based, he argued, then the lawsuit should still stand.

On rebuttal, Bash said Native Hawaiians are not a race, but have a special political status and trust relationship with the federal government first demonstrated under the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act and dozens of other federal laws since then, including after the Rice v. Cayetano ruling in 2000.

As for the contracts and agreements Kamehameha still has on campus, Bash called them “gift conditions” and said none implicate race. For example, Bash — a white, Republican, former U.S. attorney from Texas and special assistant to President Donald Trump, who at one point was in the running to replace Ken Paxton as state attorney general — said he had no trouble using an on-campus vending machine recently.

In the end, the judge did not immediately rule on Kamehameha’s motion to dismiss the case. Smith also left the courtroom without indicating when he might issue a ruling, but previous decisions in the case have come in a couple weeks of a hearing.

Latest From Civil Beat

Blaze Lovell is a reporter for Honolulu Civil Beat.